Connecticut has pretty strict rules that employers must follow if they want to take deductions off of an employee’s salary. Typically, an employer must seek CTDOL approval for all sorts of deductions, which I covered back in a 2012 post.
But what happens if an employer makes a mistake on a paycheck and overpays an employee. What then?
That situation is not uncommon. Most of the time, employees will note the mistake and return the money to the employer — no questions asked.
But I’ve heard of other instances where the employee cashes the check and then, say, buys a used car with the mistake. Or the employee just says no. What then?
Well, I’ve received informal indications from the CTDOL that in those cases, the agency allows for the use of deductions to recover clerical errors. The employer may try to work out an agreement or payment schedule to recover the money in an orderly manner.
I would add that the employer should really be sure that whatever deductions are made from future salary payments leave enough that the employer is really paying minimum wage for the week. That should avoid any issue with a claim that minimum wage laws aren’t be followed.
In short, employees don’t get to profit from employer paycheck mistakes and employers are free to engage in a bit of self-help to recover the funds … if it’s really necessary.