Some cases turn on a single smoking gun. A new case in Connecticut turned on the smoking gun (or joint) that the employer could not prove.

Yesterday, the Connecticut Appellate Court affirmed a CHRO ruling that an employer discriminated against an employee with PTSD when it fired her after a positive marijuana test in a case with facts dating back a decade. It has some interesting nuggets for employers to consider.

Background

The employee was, by the referee’s account, an excellent worker. Apart from some tardiness, she was hardworking, took on extra assignments, and often finished her work faster than her coworkers.

Like a lot of employers, the company had a drug-free workplace policy. It barred employees from being under the influence of marijuana at work and from possessing or using it on company property. It also allowed testing on reasonable suspicion and called for termination after a positive test.

In late May 2016, the employee was diagnosed with PTSD, and a doctor recommended her for Connecticut’s medical marijuana program.

A few weeks later, she had car trouble during a break. Two coworkers stopped to help her with the oil dipstick and noticed a marijuana smell coming from the car. Neither saw her smoking or with marijuana, and neither saw smoke coming from the car. One of them reported it to a supervisor.

The next day, HR met with her. She said she hadn’t used marijuana at work or on company property and that she wasn’t the only person who used the car. She also said she had used marijuana in the past 30 days and had applied for the medical marijuana program. HR asked her doctor for verification. The doctor faxed a note confirming the PTSD diagnosis and the recommendation for medical marijuana.

The company then had her take a saliva test and put her on paid leave. She tested positive and was fired that same day, June 15, 2016, for violating the drug-free workplace policy.

The CHRO’s human rights referee found disability discrimination under CFEPA and awarded her $62,530. The referee also ordered the company to reimburse the state $9,646 for unemployment benefits. The Superior Court affirmed, and so did the Appellate Court.

There’s several takeaways from the case, so let’s take them one by one:

Takeaway #1: CFEPA’s Definition of Disability Is Broader Than the ADA’s

This point gets lost a lot, so it bears repeating.

The trial court threw out the ADA federal law finding because her PTSD did not substantially limit a major life activity, which the ADA requires. But that didn’t matter under state law. CFEPA defines mental disability by reference to the American Psychiatric Association’s DSM, and PTSD is in the DSM.

If your managers evaluate disability claims under the federal standard alone, they are working from the wrong playbook in Connecticut.

Takeaway #2: Timing Matters (A Lot)

The company argued that a single medical note mentioning PTSD was the only information it had about her condition.

The court didn’t buy it. The doctor faxed the diagnosis to the company six days before the termination. That sequence was enough to support an inference of discrimination. The court also noted that the evidence needed for that inference is “minimal”.

Once a diagnosis lands in HR’s inbox, the clock starts. Any adverse action that follows soon after will be viewed in that light.

Takeaway #3: Your Policy Means What It Says

The company seemingly had a good argument in its pocket, namely that the policy prohibited being under the influence at work and using or possessing marijuana on company property.

But as the case suggests, a positive saliva test does not, by itself, prove either. The referee found no credible evidence that she broke the policy. She wasn’t seen smoking, didn’t slur her words, didn’t have drugs on her, and showed no sign of impairment at work. The two coworkers also gave inconsistent accounts of whether she seemed under the influence. With no policy violation, the stated reason was found to be false, and that falsity supported a finding of pretext.

Review your drug and alcohol policy with that line in mind. Does it target impairment and on-site use? Does it separate a positive test from proof of a violation? Does it address employees who are, or say they are, in the medical marijuana program?

Takeaway #4: Investigate Before You Decide

The opinion includes two details in a footnote worth highlighting as well.

First, the opinion suggests that the company didn’t interview the coworkers who sat next to her. It also had cameras on every corner of the building and never reviewed the footage of the parking lot from that day.

It’s easy to do some Monday morning quarterbacking on whether the video would’ve mattered at all. But the opinion does suggest that the employer may not have done as thorough an investigation as it would’ve liked.

Takeaway #5: Pick a Reason and Stick With It

Before the public hearing, the only reason the company had given (at least according to the court’s opinion) for the firing was the drug policy violation. At the hearing, it also pointed to her tardiness and to her statement that she already had a medical marijuana card.

The referee treated those shifting explanations as evidence of pretext, and the court agreed, citing Second Circuit authority that inconsistent or after-the-fact reasons can suggest a discriminatory motive.

Document the real reason when you make the decision. If other issues mattered, say so then.

The Bottom Line

Employers can still enforce drug-free workplace policies in Connecticut. But as this case demonstrates, a smell in a parking lot and a positive test, arriving days after the employer learns of a diagnosis, may be a shaky foundation for a termination.