Today, the U.S. Department of Labor announced its final rule on who counts as an employee and who counts as an independent contractor. It takes effect 60 days after it’s published in the Federal Register in the next day or so.

For businesses that rely on contractors, the headlines will sound like good news. And at the federal level, they mostly are.

But if you’re in Connecticut, the federal rule is the easy part.

The Federal Rule, in Brief

The new rule throws out the 2024 Biden-era test and goes back to something close to the 2021 approach from the first Trump administration. (Yes, this is the third version in about five years. Try to keep up.)

The question is still whether the worker is in business for himself or herself, or is economically dependent on the company for work. But the rule now puts two “core factors” front and center:

  • Control. Who decides the schedule, the workload, the projects, and whether the worker can work for others?
  • Opportunity for profit or loss. Can the worker make or lose money through real business decisions or investment? Earning more by working more hours doesn’t count.

When those two factors point the same way, the USDOL says that will almost always be the right answer. Three other factors (skill, permanence, and whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production) come in mainly when the core factors split.

Two other points are worth knowing. Actual practice matters more than what the contract says is possible. And the same test now applies under the FMLA, not just the FLSA.

Net result: for federal purposes, classifying someone as a contractor should be somewhat more predictable and straightforward.

Connecticut Plays by a Different Set of Rules

Now for the part that matters for Connecticut employers.

Connecticut doesn’t use the federal economic reality test for its own purposes. The Connecticut Department of Labor uses the “ABC test”.

Under the ABC test, a worker is an employee unless the company proves all three of these:

  • A. The worker is free from the company’s direction and control, both under the contract and in fact.
  • B. The work is performed outside the company’s usual course of business, or outside all of its places of business.
  • C. The worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, profession, or business of the same nature.

I’ve said before that it’s not as easy as ABC. It still isn’t. Here’s why Connecticut’s test is tougher than the new federal one.

It starts with a presumption of employment. The statute treats the service as employment “unless and until” the company shows otherwise. The burden is on employers.

It’s all or nothing. The federal rule weighs factors. Connecticut’s test is conjunctive, so if you miss any one prong, the worker is an employee.

Control is measured by the right to control. According to the CTDOL, Part A fails if the company keeps the right to direct and control the work, even if it never uses that right. The federal rule focuses more on what actually happens day to day.

A newly formed LLC won’t save you. The CTDOL says a worker who forms a business in response to an offer of contractor work doesn’t meet Part C. The good news is that working for only one company isn’t automatically fatal; the Connecticut Supreme Court looks at the totality of the circumstances.

To be fair, the courts have given employers some breathing room. In Standard Oil, the Connecticut Supreme Court held that customers’ homes weren’t the company’s “places of business” under Part B and found the installers to be independent contractors. But those were cases about meeting the ABC test. The test itself didn’t change.

And Connecticut has more than one test. The Department of Revenue Services follows common-law rules, and the Workers’ Compensation Commission looks at other factors. So the same worker can come out differently depending on which agency is asking.

What Connecticut Employers Should Do Now

The bottom line is simple. If a worker passes the new federal test, that tells you nothing about Connecticut. You need to meet Connecticut’s standard, and that’s the harder one.

In practice, that means:

  • Run every Connecticut contractor through the ABC test first. If the relationship holds up there, it will likely hold up federally. The reverse isn’t true.
  • Look at the contract and the reality. Remove language that reserves control you don’t need, and then make sure you don’t exercise that control in practice.
  • Check Part C. Does the contractor have other clients, a business presence, insurance, and a real independent trade? Or did the business show up the week you made the offer?
  • Pay close attention to anyone doing your core work at your locations. That’s where Part B gets hard.

None of this means you can’t use independent contractors in Connecticut. You can. But the relationship has to be legitimate under Connecticut’s test, not just Washington’s.

The new federal rule makes the federal question a little easier. In Connecticut, the hard question hasn’t changed.